Forward of Friday’s debut of HomePod, choose publications got early hands-on time with the machine. Their evaluations had been largely combined, praising the sound of HomePod however discovering that Siri simply cannot compete —but.
The New York Occasions
Reviewer Brian X. Cheng rated HomePod alongside Amazon Echo and Google House in a complete of 14 completely different duties. Every was rated on a scale of zero to four, zero for duties that weren’t attainable, 2 for accomplished with some points, and four for flawless operation.
In these rankings, HomePod got here in final, with a rating of two.9. Google House was barely higher with three.1, and Amazon Echo was the clear winner with a three.four.
Chen discovered that Siri and Apple Music didn’t study his style in music even after every week’s price of use, recommending artists he was not considering. It was additionally unable to correctly pronounce some artist names, like Tupac.
Outdoors of music, HomePod was unable to faucet into third-party apps like Uber, nor present recipes, and even entry a calendar. Google House and Amazon Echo, nonetheless, dealt with all of these duties.
Chen did say that HomePod outperformed the competitors in sensible house performance, the place setup was simpler on Apple’s HomeKit platform. And the HomePod speaker did outperform Amazon and Google by way of audio high quality.
When requested about Siri’s shortcomings, Apple instructed the Occasions that it centered on fundamental duties for launch, and future capabilities can be evaluated over time. Chen’s conclusion: “Do not rush to purchase it.”
The HomePod is a “lonely” product, within the phrases of reviewer Nilay Patel. Whereas it presents “superb” sound high quality, the machine is locked nearly solely inside Apple’s ecosystem.
Patel got here away impressed by the flexibility of HomePod to dynamically regulate its audio based mostly on environment. The complicated course of takes about 10 seconds of taking part in music with none help wanted from the consumer.
“HomePod sounds noticeably richer and fuller than nearly each different speaker we have examined,” he stated. “You get a surprisingly spectacular quantity of bass out of it, however you may nonetheless hear the entire particulars within the midrange and the bass by no means overwhelms the music.”
However when it got here to Siri, Patel’s reward was restricted. He admitted that the microphones are good at listening for “Hey Siri” instructions, however that is about the place the compliments ended.
Among the many points that Patel discovered with Siri on HomePod, it can not set two timers directly, it can not search for a recipe, it can not make a cellphone name by itself, it does not management content material on Apple TV, and it does not acknowledge completely different consumer voices.
Particularly, he discovered it to be an alarming safety situation that anybody might ship or learn textual content messages from the first iPhone whether it is linked to the identical Wi-Fi community.
“I attempted the HomePod behind a closed door and it picked up my voice and it fortunately learn my texts aloud, a nightmare for anybody who lives in a dorm,” he stated.
In conclusion, he stated that HomePod is right for purchasers who dwell “solely inside Apple’s walled backyard and prioritize sound high quality over every thing else.” Most prospects, he stated, can be higher served by different sensible audio system.
Pitting HomePod towards Sonos One, Google Max and Amazon Echo, Jim Dalrymple found “no comparability in sound high quality,” saying it was “actually laughable” to listen to the others in distinction to Apple’s machine.
“It is laborious to elucidate the sound of HomePod, however you get a sense that the sound is enveloping you, even when utilizing only one speaker,” he stated. “There’s a sense that that is how the songwriter and producer needed the music to be heard after they recorded it.”
Dalrymple was additionally impressed by the HomePod’s capability to listen to “Hey Siri” instructions, even when loud music is taking part in. On this division, he stated he was unable to get the system to fail.
Duties he used exterior of music included including groceries to a Reminder listing, studying messages, handing off a cellphone name, and accessing data like information, visitors, sports activities and climate. He did name out the shortage of entry to calendars, nonetheless.
He additionally shared HomePod with mates by way of the House app, giving customers authorization to regulate units, and even play music by way of AirPlay from companies apart from Apple Music.
“There could also be issues that the opposite units can do, like buying from Amazon or including objects to Google Specific buying, however none of these are that necessary to me,” Dalrymple stated. “I’ve entry to my Groceries buying listing, I can add notes, take cellphone calls, ship Messages, management my house, and ask Siri tons of questions. On prime of all that, I’ve the most effective sounding audio system available on the market.”
The Wall Avenue Journal
HomePod has a “sensational voice,” reviewer Joanna Stern said, however the machine nonetheless “must work on its mind.”
In a single check, Stern positioned the HomePod onstage at a 450-seat theater. With quantity set to most, she might clearly and “fantastically” hear the audio from the final row.
In distinction, Google’s pricier $400 House Max speaker was louder, however the audio was distorted at most quantity. Stern additionally discovered that Google’s microphones couldn’t choose up voice instructions correctly when music was taking part in loudly.
As with different evaluations, Stern discovered that HomePod falls quick when it depends on Siri for sensible speaker features, like setting a customized alarm, having a number of timers, accessing calendars, and even making a cellphone name by itself.
“It actually comes right down to what you need your speaker to do,” she stated. “If you’d like the neatest sensible speaker, this is not it. However in case you prize music above every thing else, the HomePod is not a dumb alternative.”
USA Today’s Ed Baig praised the straightforward setup of HomePod, the superior sound high quality, and the flexibility to know “Hey Siri” in a wide range of environments. However the lack of entry to third-party apps, the restricted capabilities of Siri, and incompatibility with customary Bluetooth units like Android handsets had been all knocks towards the product.
CNet’s Megan Wollerton stated iPhone customers who worth sound high quality over all else ought to take into account the HomePod. However these searching for an Amazon Alexa competitor can be left wanting.
TechCrunch’s Matthew Panzarino stated HomePod is “simply one of the best sounding mainstream sensible speaker ever.” He stated it is a straightforward advice for Apple Music customers who need superior sound high quality, however its “best-in-class voice recognition” is “stymied by the restricted command units that the Siri protocol presents.”
Buzzfeed’s Nicole Nguyen was impressed that Siri knew what she meant when she requested it to play the artist SZA —Alexa performed both Sizzla or John Philip Souza as a substitute. However she additionally dinged Siri for restricted understanding of instructions: “I do not like this” was not acknowledged, however “I do not like this music” labored positive.
(function(d, s, id) (document, ‘script’, ‘facebook-jssdk’));https://connect.facebook.net/en_US/all.js#xfbml=1