Roku has been giving numerous like to over-the-air antennas these days, however solely on its sensible TVs.
Roku TVs from TCL, Hisense, and others have supported pausing over-the-air channels since final fall, and now the corporate is constructing on these options with Roku OS 8. When the replace lands on Roku TVs in November, cord-cutters will get a 14-day channel information, which additionally lists whether or not every program is accessible from streaming sources. Native TV listings will seem in Roku Search as nicely, and stay broadcasts will help personal listening, both by way of Roku’s cell app or any Roku distant that has a headphone jack.
Sadly, none of this over-the-air innovation is accessible on Roku’s streaming gamers, together with the slew of new Roku boxes and sticks introduced this week. That’s as a result of Roku gives no method to join an antenna on to its gamers. You’ll be able to nonetheless join an antenna on to your TV, after all, however you then get not one of the wealthy information information, search integration, and time-shifting that Roku TVs provide.
Roku isn’t alone on this regard. Amazon additionally gives some slick antenna integration on its Fire TV Edition televisions, together with time-shifting, a grid-based channel information, home-screen integration for stay channels, and the power to tune into channels by voice. None of these options can be found on Amazon’s Hearth TV field or Hearth TV Stick, which lack the requisite enter for an antenna. (Amazon’s product page for the new Fire TV says you may “Use an HD antenna to get free broadcast networks like NBC and PBS,” however this has nothing to do with the Hearth TV itself. It’s only a reference to the coaxial enter on virtually each tv.)
There are a number of reputable challenges that Roku and Amazon face in bringing antenna help to their streaming gamers. However as antenna use grows in tandem with the streaming-player enterprise, these challenges appear price fixing for the sake of an easier cord-cutting expertise.
The enter drawback
The largest concern has to do with inputs. If Roku or Amazon needed to incorporate over-the-air integration on their streaming bins, they’d both want a coaxial enter and TV tuner contained in the field itself, or on a separate USB tuner. Each approaches deliver trade-offs.
Direct coaxial enter would enhance the scale and value of the streaming gadget. That’s most likely one thing Roku and Amazon wish to keep away from, on condition that antenna customers are only a subset of the general streaming-player market.
An non-compulsory USB tuner may make extra sense, however units just like the Roku Extremely and Hearth TV field solely have one USB port. To pause or rewind stay TV, the gadget would both want a second USB port for exterior storage, or ample built-in storage for briefly saving the video. Both manner, you’re again to the issue of added gadget prices for a function that just some folks may use. This might be solved with a USB hub gadget, by way of which customers may join each a tuner and a storage drive, nevertheless it’s laborious to think about Roku or Amazon backing such an unwieldy answer.
In addition to, neither firm helps full-blown DVR options, even on their sensible TVs. You’ll be able to pause stay TV, however you may’t schedule recordings, arrange sequence passes, or document multiple channel at a time. With out these options, an funding in additional antenna could be more durable to justify.
In lieu of antenna integration from Roku and Amazon, different firms have give you their very own options.
One possibility is a networked DVR or tuner, resembling Nuvyyo’s Tablo and SiliconDust’s HDHomeRun. These units hook up with your router—the previous by way of Wi-Fi or ethernet, and the latter by way of ethernet solely—and stream stay TV to apps on varied units. Tablo can also be a full-blown DVR, as is HDHomeRun in case you have the required . Each provide apps for Roku and Hearth TV, however sadly, neither possibility integrates with search on these units.
Should you’re not married to Roku or Hearth TV, Google’s Android TV platform permits for the type of tuner integration that these units lack. With Nvidia’s Shield TV, as an example, you may join a supported USB tuner and watch broadcast channels by way of Android TV’s Stay Channels app. You may as well add DVR service with Tablo Engine or Plex DVR.
Sling TV subscribers must also think about the AirTV Participant, one other Android TV field that has its personal USB tuner. With this gadget, over-the-air and streaming cable channels seem collectively in Sling’s programming information. Whereas AirTV didn’t fare well in our review earlier this yr, the gadget has steadily improved in latest months with a greater information and DVR for cable channels. AirTV was additionally prescient sufficient to incorporate two USB slots, in case the corporate will get round to including over-the-air DVR help.
Antenna use is on the rise. Based on Parks Associates, 15 % of U.S. properties with broadband service used an antenna instead of traditional pay TV service in Q3 2016, up from round 10 % a pair years earlier. Over-the-air has develop into so prevalent that Nielsen is now tracking antenna channel viewership in lots of markets, because it does with cable.
My wildly speculative guess is that Roku and Amazon are watching these traits, and slowly working as much as one thing they’ll provide to antenna customers by way of their streaming bins. By beginning with sensible TVs, they’ll put the items collectively on the software program facet with out driving up prices or requiring any further . Hopefully it will not be lengthy earlier than they make leap to streaming bins as nicely.
Join Jared’s Cord Cutter Weekly newsletter to get this column and different cord-cutting information, insights, and offers delivered to your inbox.