On a latest journey to my dad and mom’ place in New Hampshire, I cooked up some hen leg quarters on the Traeger Timberline 850 grill that I’d introduced alongside to overview. I set it to the precise temperature the producer steered, lit the grill with the press of a button, and, utilizing an app, remotely monitored each the temperature within the grill and the interior temperature of the legs and thighs as they cooked.
When the hen reached 165 levels Fahrenheit, I opened the grill, anticipating smoke-tinged hen perfection. As an alternative, I referred to as mother for assist.
The interior temperature certainly learn an ideal 165, however the pores and skin was rubbery and there was no means I used to be going to get the warmth jacked as much as searing temperature with out severely delaying dinner and probably overcooking the meals. As an alternative, my mother browned the pores and skin in a skillet on the range, saving dinner. The hen turned out so implausible that I puzzled if the producer’s product and recipe testers instinctively counted on us to ask the girl who introduced us into the world to come back to the rescue.
Traeger Timberline 850
Push-button ignition on a grill/smoker that has glorious temperature management expertise. Super potential with Wi-Fi connection and an app.
That potential shouldn’t be lived as much as. Mechanical bugs like thermometers that misinterpret the temperature and should not in a position to be calibrated are main whiffs, contemplating the $1,700 price ticket.
The Traeger Timberline 850 is what’s often called a pellet cooker, and this episode encapsulated a number of the finest strengths and weaknesses of the machine. Pellet cookers are likely to have a recognizable grill-like inside, and a hopper filled with wooden pellets on the aspect, that are transported to a “burn pot” underneath the grill grates through a mechanized auger. (Or, as my spouse put it: “You push the wooden pellets in and it burns them.”) The grill plugs into an outlet, permitting that auger to work and providing push-button ignition. The Traeger has a thermocouple probe on the prime proper of the inside, serving to it to observe the temperature and holding it regular like an oven, whereas imparting a stunning smoky taste. For lengthy, low, and sluggish cooks—splendid for meals like brisket—pellet cookers are stunningly efficient. Searing, nevertheless, is their Achilles heel, which made me want that Traeger would substitute the stubby grill desk on the left aspect of the Timberline with an electrical griddle that might make searing a snap.
The Timberline additionally options Wi-Fi connectivity, permitting three-way communication between the app, the grill, and the cloud. There’s some implausible potential right here, however that is Traeger’s first foray into linked cooking and the dearth of expertise exhibits. Mix that with some mechanical difficulties and the grill concurrently costs into the longer term and shoots itself within the foot. Pretty inexcusable, contemplating that it prices $1,700.
Smoke It If You’ve Received It
The potential right here is big. The flexibility to easily set the temperature and stroll away gives an enormous quantity of management, a distinction exacerbated once you swap again to a “common” fuel grill or Weber kettle. Set a brisket to 180 and monitor the interior temperature because of the built-in probe thermometer and you start to understand you could possibly, with lengthy, low-temp cooks, crib recipes from a sous vide cookbook and get implausible, smoky outcomes. Pair that with an app that would perceive what’s taking place when you cook dinner, and also you’ve obtained a recreation changer.
But after I made beef brisket (Traeger’s “Newbie’s Brisket”), the one recipe that each one pellet cookers ought to merely crush, limitations and defects have been uncovered. Most notable was the discrepancy between the set temperature of 180 levels Fahrenheit and the precise temp the grill cooked at for the primary two and a half hours—between 196 and 221—adopted by a quick dip to 161 and a return to 190. Roughly, that meant it cooked about 20 levels larger than the temperature it was set to for the primary 4 hours of the cook dinner. Once I swung the temp as much as 250 for the later phases of cooking, it did a tremendous job of staying inside a pair levels of the goal. (These spectacular outcomes have been repeated a couple of days later after I made ribs at 225 levels.)
Towards the tip of the brisket’s cook dinner, I encountered a well-known drawback often called “the stall,” the place the interior temperature of the brisket climbed steadily towards a goal temperature of 203 levels, however plateaued at round 190 for a couple of maddening hours. Should you notice it’s taking place, you may get round by jacking up the grill temperature, or tightly wrapping the brisket with foil (a.ok.a. “the Texas crutch”). If the grill or app is aware of the temperature curve has flattened on the typical stall temperature, why not have the app alert me and inform me some choices as an alternative of pushing dinnertime into bedtime?
However, it was a implausible brisket, with a darkish exterior “bark” and the pink circle simply beneath referred to as a smoke ring, an indication of high quality so pronounced that appeared prefer it was painted on with lipstick.
That temperature discrepancy within the first part of the cook dinner made me marvel in regards to the accuracy of the thermometer, so I caught the Traeger’s probe thermometer underneath my tongue and discovered that both the thermometer was off by nearly 10 levels or I used to be experiencing a freak assault of hypothermia.
For comparability, I put my mother’s years-old Pyrex meat thermometer underneath my tongue and the dial pointed towards 98.5.
I ordered a ThermoWorks Smoke, a grill thermometer with each a probe thermometer to trace inner temperatures of what you’re cooking and an “air probe” that clips to the grill and screens the cooking temperature; basically, replicating the identical setup constructed into the Traeger. Naturally, I put the ThermoWorks cooking probe underneath my tongue and discovered that I used to be operating at 97.2 levels, however for extra accuracy, I created a 32-degree ice bath. The ThermoWorks probes and my mother’s Pyrex all clocked in inside a level, however the Traeger probe learn 26.
The ThermoWorks Smoke has large magnets on the again and it clamped onto the aspect of the grill with gusto, as if it was wanting to bore by way of the Traeger’s hull and suck out its brains. I positioned the ThermoWorks “air probe” subsequent to the Traeger’s and located that the smoker ran six to 10 levels larger than the temperature it was set at.
That is unhealthy however forgivable for the set temperature of the grill. On the Traeger’s probe thermometer, although, it’s tougher to disregard. These levels of distinction signifies that what reads as uncommon comes out as medium-rare, medium is medium-well, and well-done is a briquette. What’s actually unforgivable? You possibly can’t calibrate the Traeger’s thermometers. (Requested about this, a spokesman mentioned, “We’d substitute them if there was ever a necessity.”)
Meaning any programmed cooks I made had built-in flaws that pressured me to purchase a $100 grill thermometer that I might calibrate. With this setup in the long run, I’d must forgo a lot of the attract and promise of the linked capabilities of the grill.
Carry the Warmth
Sadly, there’s extra. Once I made ribs, I turned up the temperature towards the tip of the cook dinner to get some caramelization and searing. Once I returned a couple of minutes later, the temperature hadn’t gone up however there was a clinking sound I mistook for the hearth gaining momentum. As an alternative, I’d study that the hearth had gone out and the auger saved pushing pellets into the underside of the grill.
I fished the ribs on my dad’s grill.
The app was additionally a disappointment, principally as a result of there was little to no worth added by utilizing it. Creating customized cooks contained in the app looks as if a pure, however for causes I don’t perceive, you may solely make them utilizing the dial on the aspect of the grill; have enjoyable typing in “Aunt Janice’s world-famous pulled pork” with that setup. Equally, why not ship an alarm to the app when a goal temperature is reached, and drop the grill temperature to forestall overcooking? How about instructing it to cope with “the stall”?
Traeger might additionally do with some extra fashionable recipe choices, and ensure these recipes are examined. I bumped into bother the place programmed recipes marched on from one step within the recipe to the subsequent with out finishing the primary. One other programmed cook dinner referred to as for a probe within the app, however not on the machine. The smoked salmon recipe marinates the fish for two to four hours in a “beg.” Plus, the grill temps in Traeger’s recipes are typically larger than more-trusted fashionable cookbooks like Meathead Goldwyn’s Meathead or Stephen Raichlen’s Smoke.
I did make some nice meals with the Traeger, and the general potential has me wanting to see how this specific model of good grill develops within the subsequent few years.
That mentioned, whereas lots of the Timberline’s issues are fixable with software program updates, a few of them, like the dearth of a searing choice or the lack to calibrate the thermometers, depart this machine hobbled from the get go. And at $1,700, that’s so much to abdomen.
While you purchase one thing utilizing the retail hyperlinks in our product critiques, we earn a small affiliate fee. Read more about how this works.